Typewriter vs Computer

What's the difference between a manual and electric typewriter?

A manual typewriter is powered entirely by your keystrokes; an electric one uses a motor. Compare touch, upkeep, portability, features and how to choose.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. Power
  3. Touch and typing feel
  4. Consistency of print
  5. Features
  6. Portability and noise
  7. Repairs and upkeep
  8. Electric vs electronic
  9. Which should you choose?

Short answer

A manual typewriter is powered by your fingers: the force you put into each key moves the mechanism that strikes the paper. An electric typewriter uses a motor to supply that force, so each key needs only a light touch. Manual machines need no electricity and are generally simpler and more portable. Electric machines are generally easier on the fingers and print more evenly, but they are heavier, need a power outlet and have more parts that can age or fail.

Power

A manual typewriter needs only paper and a ribbon, so you can use it anywhere there is a flat surface. An electric typewriter needs to be plugged in, which ties it to a desk near an outlet. Electric machines also differ in how they use that power: some drive only the typing action, and others also handle the carriage return and other functions.

Touch and typing feel

On a manual, you supply all the force. Keys usually require a firm, decisive press, and the way you strike each key affects how dark or light the letter prints. Many typists enjoy this feedback; others find it tiring on long documents.

On an electric, the motor does the work, so the keys feel lighter and the action is more like a computer keyboard. Some typists find this faster and more comfortable. Others miss the mechanical feel of a manual.

Consistency of print

Because an electric typewriter delivers the same impact every time, the printing tends to be more even from letter to letter. On a manual, uneven pressure shows on the page: a weak little finger can give a pale letter “a”, and a heavy hand can punch through thin paper. With practice you can get a consistent result, but it takes technique.

Features

Manual typewriters are mostly basic. They often have margin stops, tab stops, a ribbon selector and a bell that rings near the right margin. Many electric and electronic models add features such as:

  • an automatic carriage return;
  • a repeat key for held characters;
  • built-in correction tape (some models) to lift or cover mistakes;
  • on some electronic models, a small display and memory that let you edit a line before it prints.

For how mistakes are handled on each type, see fixing mistakes on a typewriter vs pressing undo on a computer.

Portability and noise

Many manual portables are designed to fit into a case and be carried. Electric typewriters are usually heavier and bulkier and are meant to stay put. Both are noisy compared with a computer keyboard, though the sound differs: a manual has the sharp clack of typebars, and an electric adds the hum of the motor.

Repairs and upkeep

A manual typewriter has no electrical parts, so there is less that can go wrong, and many problems come down to dirt, dried oil or worn parts that can be cleaned or adjusted. Electric machines have motors, wiring and often belts and rubber parts that can harden or perish with age. They can still last a long time, but repairs may be less straightforward, and finding parts or a repairer depends on the model.

Electric vs electronic

These terms are often confused:

  • Electric typewriters use a motor to power a mechanical typing action. The IBM Selectric, with its rotating type element, is a well-known example (see types of typewriters).
  • Electronic typewriters use electronic circuits, and often a printing element such as a daisy wheel. Many have memory or a display.

Both are different from a word processor or a laptop. If you are interested in that comparison, see word processors vs typewriters.

Which should you choose?

  • Choose a manual if you want something simple, portable and mechanical, and you do not mind pressing firmly.
  • Choose an electric if you plan to type long documents at a desk and want lighter keys and even printing.
  • Check the condition of any used machine before you buy, whichever type it is. A typewriter that has been stored for years may need cleaning and a new ribbon, and an electric one may need more than that.

For a buyer’s feature-by-feature comparison, see manual vs electronic typewriters.

For the bigger picture of how typewriters compare with modern tools, see typewriter vs computer: 10 key differences.

The complete guide to typewriter vs computer

Typewriter vs Computer: 10 Key Differences
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →