Short answer
A manual typewriter keyboard and a computer keyboard share the same basic letter layout, but they work in different ways. On a typewriter, each key is part of a mechanical linkage that physically moves a character to the paper. On a computer, each key is a switch that sends a signal to software. This is why computer keyboards have many extra keys and a lighter touch, while typewriters have mechanical controls such as a carriage return and margin settings.
What they share
Most typewriters and computer keyboards in English-speaking countries use the QWERTY arrangement, so the main letter keys are in the same places. That is one reason touch typing skills carry over between the two. Both have a space bar, a Shift key for capital letters and symbols, a Tab key, and a row of number keys above the letters.
How a key works
On a typebar typewriter, pressing a key moves a series of levers that swing a metal character against the ribbon and paper. The force you apply is transferred through the mechanism, which is why the key feels heavier and why the machine makes the familiar clacking sound. Some designs, such as typeball or daisy-wheel machines, work differently but still strike physically.
A computer key is a switch under the keycap. Pressing it closes a circuit (or registers a touch) and the keyboard sends a code to the computer. The key itself does not need to push anything to the page, so designers are free to make the key shorter, lighter, quieter or backlit. Mechanical computer keyboards use individual switches and can be quite loud, but they still send signals rather than moving type.
Controls a typewriter has that a computer keyboard doesn’t
Typewriters carry functions that have no direct key on a computer:
- Carriage return lever or key. On a manual machine you push the carriage back to the start of the next line, which also advances the paper. The Return or Enter key on a computer takes its name from this.
- Margin stops and margin release. You set left and right margins mechanically and use the margin release key to type beyond them.
- Tab set and clear. Tab stops are set by hand on most manuals, rather than in a document ruler.
- Ribbon selector and ribbon reverse. These choose which part of the ribbon strikes the paper, and many machines have a stencil setting that lifts the ribbon out of the way.
- Paper release and platen knob. These are used to align paper or fix crooked pages, and they are not keyboard keys.
- Backspace. On many manual typewriters this moves the carriage one space back without erasing anything. It is not the same as the Backspace key on a computer, which deletes.
Some older typewriters also leave out certain characters. A common example is a missing number 1 and 0, where typists use the lowercase “l” and capital “O” instead. This varies by model, so it is worth checking the machine you have. More quirks are listed in parts and characteristics of a typewriter keyboard.
Keys a computer keyboard has that a typewriter doesn’t
- Delete and Backspace that remove text.
- Function keys (F1 to F12), Escape and arrow keys, which control software and move the cursor.
- Ctrl, Alt, Windows or Command keys used for shortcuts such as copy and paste.
- Caps Lock and often a numeric keypad. (Typewriters have a shift lock, the ancestor of Caps Lock.)
- Media and system keys on many modern keyboards.
For the difference between a keyboard and a keypad, see what is the difference between a keypad and a keyboard.
Feel and force
Typewriter keys generally require a firmer press and move further than the keys on a typical computer keyboard. Electric and electronic typewriters sit in between, because a motor or electronics does some of the work. If you want to compare the models, see the difference between a manual and an electric typewriter. Many people enjoy the feedback of a typewriter, while others find the extra force tiring over a long session.
Which is better for typing?
It depends on what you value. A computer keyboard is easier on the fingers for long periods and lets you correct mistakes instantly. A typewriter keyboard rewards a steady, deliberate rhythm, and each key press produces a permanent mark. Neither is objectively better; they suit different goals. For a comparison of speed, see typewriter vs keyboard typing speed.
Moving between the two
If you are used to a computer keyboard, expect to:
- Press harder, and with more even force, so letters print consistently.
- Return the carriage by hand and listen for the bell as you near the margin.
- Avoid relying on Delete or undo; see fixing mistakes on a typewriter.
Going the other way, you may find yourself pressing too hard on a computer keyboard at first. For the wider comparison, see typewriter vs computer: 10 key differences.