Short answer
For most people, a computer keyboard is faster in practice, mainly because the keys are lighter and mistakes can be fixed instantly. But the machine is only part of the story: a trained typist can be quick on either, and the gap in raw keystrokes per minute is smaller than the gap in finished pages per hour. There is no single number that applies to everyone.
What affects typing speed
- Skill and practice. Touch typing with all fingers usually matters more than the hardware.
- Key force and travel. Manual typewriter keys generally need a firmer press and move further than most computer keys, so each stroke takes a little more effort. Electric typewriters reduce this effort.
- Accuracy. Typing quickly with many errors is slower overall than typing a little more slowly with few errors.
- Familiarity. Switching machines usually costs you speed for a while.
- Fatigue. Heavy keys can tire your hands over long sessions, especially if you are not used to them.
Be cautious about published speed claims for keyboards. Figures for mechanical keyboards or other types vary by study, sample and testing method, and they do not describe typewriters.
Raw speed vs finished-page speed
It helps to separate two ideas:
- Raw typing speed: how fast your fingers can produce characters.
- Finished-page speed: how long it takes to produce a clean, correct page.
On raw speed, a skilled typist may do well on a manual typewriter, particularly if they learned on one. On finished-page speed, the computer has a big advantage. Every error on a typewriter costs time to correct, cover or retype; see fixing mistakes on a typewriter vs pressing undo. On a computer, an error costs a keystroke or two, and you can rearrange paragraphs without retyping.
Manual vs electric vs computer keyboards
- Manual typewriter: most effort per key, but no setup and no distractions. Pace is often set by steady rhythm.
- Electric typewriter: lighter touch, even impression and often an automatic return, so long lines and pages can go faster.
- Computer keyboard: lightest touch overall and no carriage to return, so typing can flow continuously.
For more on how the machines feel and differ, see the difference between a manual and electric typewriter and typewriter vs computer keyboard.
Typebar jams and rhythm
On typebar machines, striking neighbouring keys in very quick succession can make the typebars clash, so an even rhythm tends to work better than short bursts. This is one reason people often think of typewriter typing as steady and deliberate rather than flurried. A computer keyboard has no such limit, and rollover handling means several keys pressed close together will normally register correctly.
Tips to type faster on a typewriter
- Learn to touch type if you do not already, starting from the guide keys.
- Use a steady rhythm rather than rushing.
- Press firmly and evenly so letters print cleanly the first time.
- Keep the machine clean and properly adjusted, because sticky keys slow you down.
- Return the carriage with a quick, smooth motion; with practice this adds little time.
- Make the next line start the moment the bell rings, rather than watching the margin.
Bottom line
If you want to produce finished text quickly, a computer is the faster tool for most people. If you enjoy the rhythm, or want a draft with no distractions, speed may not be the point. If you are choosing a tool for a long project, see writing a novel on a typewriter vs a computer and the broader typewriter vs computer comparison.