Typewriter vs Computer

Writing a Novel on a Typewriter vs a Computer: Pros and Cons

Should you write a novel on a typewriter or a computer? Weigh focus, editing, backups, cost and workflow, plus a hybrid approach many writers use.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. Pros of writing a novel on a typewriter
  3. Cons of writing a novel on a typewriter
  4. Pros of writing a novel on a computer
  5. Cons of writing a novel on a computer
  6. A hybrid workflow
  7. Practical points
  8. How to decide

Short answer

You can write a novel on either, and plenty of people have. A typewriter offers focus and a physical, finished-feeling first draft but makes revision, searching and backing up much harder. A computer makes revision and submission easy but offers more distractions. Many writers combine them, drafting on a typewriter and revising on a computer.

Pros of writing a novel on a typewriter

  • Focus. There are no notifications, tabs or updates, so it is easier to stay with the page.
  • Forward momentum. Because editing is awkward, you tend to keep moving rather than polishing the first paragraph forever. Some writers find this helpful for a rough first draft.
  • A physical manuscript. You can see and hold your progress as the stack grows, and the pages are a record that does not depend on a file format or a battery. A manual typewriter works without power.
  • Enjoyment. For many people, the sound and feel of the machine are part of why they write at all, and motivation counts for a lot over a long project.

Cons of writing a novel on a typewriter

  • Revision is slow. Moving a scene or rewording a chapter means retyping pages. A novel is usually revised many times, so this adds up.
  • No search. You cannot search for a character’s name, a repeated word or a timeline detail across hundreds of pages.
  • A single physical copy. Unless you copy or scan the pages, one fire, spill or lost box can take the manuscript with it.
  • Submission. Publishers and agents generally ask for digital files, so you will need to retype or scan the manuscript at some point. Check each recipient’s guidelines.
  • Cost and supplies. Paper and ribbons are ongoing costs, and a machine may need cleaning or repair along the way.
  • Noise and space. Typewriters are loud, and a full draft takes up a lot of room.

As one common view puts it, typewriters make writing permanent rather than better. They suit some writers’ habits, but they do not improve the writing on their own.

Pros of writing a novel on a computer

  • Easy revision. You can restructure, rewrite and undo changes freely. See fixing mistakes on a typewriter vs pressing undo.
  • Search and navigation. Find any name, phrase or scene, and move chapters around with ease.
  • Backups. Copies can be saved to several places, and some tools keep earlier versions.
  • Ready for submission. Files can be sent as they are, formatted as requested.
  • Spelling and grammar tools. These help with typos, though they do not replace careful proofreading.

For a longer list of what computers do well, see the advantages of a computer over a typewriter.

Cons of writing a novel on a computer

  • Distraction. The same device that holds your manuscript also holds email, social media and the web.
  • Endless tinkering. Easy editing can tempt writers to rework the opening chapter repeatedly instead of finishing a draft.
  • Dependence on power and backups. A drive failure or a missed backup can be costly if you do not plan for it.

Some writers manage distraction by turning off the network, using a full-screen writing mode, or using a simple, dedicated writing device. These devices are sometimes called electronic typewriters; for the distinction between types of typewriter, see the difference between a manual and electric typewriter.

A hybrid workflow

A common approach is:

  1. Draft on the typewriter, keeping moving and not worrying about perfect sentences.
  2. Type the draft into a computer. Retyping is slow, but it works as a second pass in which many writers revise as they go. Scanning with text recognition is another option, and it generally needs proofreading.
  3. Revise on the computer, where moving and rewriting is easy.
  4. Keep the typed pages somewhere safe as a physical backup of the first draft.

Practical points

  • Length. A double-spaced typed page holds roughly 250 to 300 words, so a typical novel runs to hundreds of pages. Buy paper and ribbons accordingly.
  • Storage. Keep pages flat, in a box, away from damp and sunlight, and number every page.
  • Backups. Photograph or scan finished chapters regularly.
  • Machine condition. If you are using an older typewriter, get it cleaned and checked before starting a long project. The same points apply as in what to check before buying a used typewriter.

How to decide

The complete guide to typewriter vs computer

Typewriter vs Computer: 10 Key Differences
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →